Initial Technical Architecture Blueprint: Fund Distribution System for the Respect Game

💡

See the introduction in this series in Optimism Fractal's Respect Game: Research into Democratic Fund Distribution

See the original research and write comments on the governance forum thread.

Overview

This blueprint establishes the technical foundations for implementing democratic fund distribution through the Respect Game at Optimism Fractal. Building on proven coordination infrastructure developed by the Optimystics team, we create a bridge between decentralized community governance and compliant fund distribution - enabling communities on the Superchain to fairly allocate capital while maintaining essential protections.

The architecture presented here represents a systematic approach to solving one of the core challenges facing the Optimism ecosystem by leveraging advanced processes for democratic coordination to enable effective resource allocation at scale. By carefully integrating existing Respect Game infrastructure with new components for fund distribution, we establish pathways for the Optimism Collective to implement sophisticated capital allocation while enabling truly democratic principles.

This research approach draws from years of research and practical implementation, combining insights from successful community coordination with rigorous analysis of technical requirements. The resulting architecture creates flexible infrastructure that communities can adapt to their specific needs while maintaining core democratic benefits. For context for these technical decisions, please review the introduction above.

Design Principles

The system architecture follows carefully considered principles that ensure both immediate effectiveness and long-term sustainability. These principles guide technical decisions while maintaining focus on the broader vision of enabling democratic coordination at scale:

Credibly Neutral Evaluation The foundation lies in peer assessment through randomized small groups, creating fair and sybil-resistant impact measurement. Local consensus decisions aggregate into sophisticated evaluation systems, allowing communities to distill collective wisdom through human-scale interactions rather than opaque global voting. By breaking complex assessments into simpler comparative decisions, we enable more accurate and scalable evaluation.

Democratic Control Fund distribution decisions flow from proven community consensus mechanisms, with Respect tokens providing transparent weighting for governance. The system preserves genuine democratic participation while enabling efficient operation through credibly neutral governance mechanisms that enable both true decentralization and efficient resource allocation while protecting against centralization.

Operational Independence Clear separation between community governance and fund execution provides essential legal protections while enabling focused participation. A dedicated legal entity handles custody requirements and compliance, allowing the community to focus on democratic coordination. This creates similar protections to the Foundation's role in RetroFunding while maintaining community autonomy.

Composable Infrastructure The architecture enables flexible combination of components to serve different community needs. Key primitives like the Respect token and consensus mechanisms can be adapted while preserving core democratic principles. This modularity allows custom governance implementations, integration with existing tools, and interoperability with various other primitives across the Superchain.

Progressive Development The system supports iterative improvement through community governance, allowing refinement of processes while maintaining stability. Each component can evolve independently as needs develop, creating resilient infrastructure for ecosystem growth. This enables gradual feature rollout, community-driven enhancement, and sustainable long-term evolution.

System Architecture

The fund distribution system comprises three interconnected layers that work together to enable democratic coordination at scale. Rather than operating entirely independently, these layers integrate closely - with core primitives like Respect tokens and role-based permissions spanning multiple layers to create sophisticated resource allocation mechanisms.

graph LR
    subgraph "Legal & Compliance Layer"
        H[KYC Attestations] --> F[Legal Entity]
        I[Legal Agreements] --> F
        F -->|Confirms| E[Role-Based Permissions]
    end

    subgraph "Community Coordination Layer"
        A[Respect Game Process] -->|Consensus| B[Respect Tokens]
        B -->|Voting Power| C[ORDAO Governance]
        B -->|Reward Multiplier| E
        C -->|Proposals| D[OREC]
    end

    subgraph "Fund Distribution Layer"
        E -->|Base Access| G[Distribution Controls]
        D -->|Execution| G
        G -->|Rewards| J[Distribution Interface]
        K[Progress Tracking] -->|Status| J
    end

Community Coordination Layer

This foundational layer provides the infrastructure for democratic evaluation and decision-making. Through careful integration of several key components, it enables genuine community governance while scaling effectively.

Respect Game

The entry point for participation lies in the core coordination mechanism - an elegant social game where participants evaluate contributions in randomized groups. Following precise specifications defined in Optimism Fractal's intents document, the process enables consistent peer evaluation while fostering meaningful community interaction. The Optimism Fractal Respect Game is played through the Fractalgram webapp, which is integrated with ORDAO smart contracts.

ORDAO Protocol

ORDAO provides sophisticated infrastructure for decentralized community coordination. Developed over years of refinement, this protocol has been successfully adopted by the Optimism Fractal community, which enables the 65 community members who participated in the first four seasons of Optimism Fractal to execute onchain actions by voting with their Respect Tokens. Learn about the Optimism Fractal community account and explore more about ORDAO in our overview article (which includes an accompanying video series).

ORDAO includes software to play the Respect Game, distribute Respect Tokens, and a powerful Optimistic Respect-based Executive Contract (OREC) which executes onchain decisions based on votes from Respect Token holders. The Respect Token and OREC are described below.

Respect Tokens

Through this peer assessment process, participants earn Respect - non-transferrable ERC-1155 tokens that provide the foundation for governance. The Respect Token system:

Records contribution evaluation through Fibonacci distribution
Enables sophisticated permission management
Creates transparent governance weighting
Provides sybil-resistant reputation tracking
Integrates with role-based access control

Optimistic Respect-based Executive Contract (OREC)

The OREC smart contract represents a breakthrough in onchain democratic execution. It enables. OREC's unique consent-based voting system overcomes traditional challenges through:

Consent-based voting with optimistic quorum
Time-delay mechanisms for community review
Integration with role-based permissions
Automated execution of approved proposals
Safeguards against centralization

This innovative contract has been tested through implementation at Optimism Fractal since the start of the community’s 5th season. The ORDAO smart contract serves an executive role that is supported by the Optimism Fractal Council, a legislative body that forms recommendations for the community. More details about their interplay will be explored in the Governance Integration Strategy Document. You can explore technical details about the Optimistic Respect-based Executive Contract in our OREC documentation and see it in action through our office hours sessions.

Legal & Compliance Layer

This crucial layer bridges decentralized community coordination with existing financial and legal systems while maintaining democratic principles. Through careful design, it provides necessary protections without sacrificing the core benefits of community governance. The legal and compliance layer is composed of three interconnected systems:

Legal Entity Infrastructure

A dedicated legal entity serves as fund custodian, structured to:

Hold and distribute funds based on community decisions
Provide clear legal protection for participants
Execute distributions proposed through OREC
Maintain operational independence from governance
Interface with traditional financial systems

The specific jurisdiction and structure will be detailed in the Legal Framework document, but key requirements include appropriate regulatory compliance while preserving maximum community autonomy.

Integrated Role & Permission System

The system combines reputation-based permissions from the Respect token with compliance requirements through:

Integration of Hats Protocol for dynamic role management
Automated verification of KYC attestations with third party providers
Clear progression paths based on participation
Granular access control for different functions

This sophisticated permissions framework, built on our award-winning Optimism Fractal Hats tree, enables both merit-based advancement and regulatory compliance.

Legal Agreement Framework

To ensure clear understanding and appropriate protections, the system includes:

Onchain agreement modules via Hats Protocol
Transparent terms of participation
Integration with role-based permissions
Automated compliance verification
Clear records of participant acceptance

Fund Distribution Layer

The final layer handles the mechanics of fund distribution while providing engaging interfaces for participation. It builds naturally on the foundations established by the community coordination and compliance layers:

Distribution Contracts

Core smart contracts manage the flow of funds through:

Integration with 0xSplits for automated distribution
Role-based access control via Hats
Verification of KYC attestations
Connection to OREC governance
Automated reward calculation
Clear audit trails of all transfers

Progress & Reward Interface

Drawing inspiration from MMORPGs and leveraging integration with Roles & Reputations software, the system provides:

Clear visualization of earned rewards
Achievement tracking and level progression
Multiple contribution pathways
Transparent status monitoring
Engaging UI for claiming and distribution proposals

Together, these three layers create a comprehensive system for democratic fund distribution. The architecture enables genuine community coordination while maintaining necessary protections and creating enjoyable participant experiences.

graph TD
    A[Respect Tokens] -->|Eligibility| B[Role Claims]
    B -->|Permission Level| C[Distribution Access]
    D[KYC Status] -->|Required| C
    E[Community Participation] -->|Earn| A

Future Development

The modular architecture allows organic evolution while preserving the core principles of democratic coordination and compliant fund distribution. The next post in this research thread will be the Governance Integration Strategy Document, which will details how the Respect Game's innovative governance protocols facilitate democratic fund distribution.

I invite you to explore the resources above to learn more about this fund distribution system, experience the Respect Game firsthand at our bi-weekly events, and turn on notifications in the thread to be notified when the next phases of research are complete. I hope you’ve enjoyed the research so far and am looking forward to hearing your thoughts. Feel free to share any comments in the thread below. And remember… stay optimistic! 🔴 ✨